UAE Federal Court Verdict on Voluntary Disclosure Form Penalties

UAE Federal Court Verdict on Voluntary Disclosure Form Penalties

Federal Court Verdict: October of 2020 was rather a significant month for the tax registrants of the country as FTA rolled out multiple clarifications and guidelines shedding light on various grey areas of tax laws in UAE. We have, in detail, discussed the clarifications through our online platforms. 

In the midst of these developments from the Federal Tax Authority (FTA), the Federal Supreme Court of United Arab Emirates (UAE) ruled a rather significant Federal Court Verdict relating to UAE VAT Voluntary Disclosure Form. At Emirates Chartered Accountants Group, we believe that this Federal Court Verdict is a landmark judgement in the chronology of VAT in UAE.

Background

The Federal Tax Authority in July 2018 issued the Voluntary Disclosure User Guide clarifying the procedures of notifying any error or omission in a tax return, refund or assessment through a Voluntary Disclosure Form. 
The guide, in detail, dealt with the procedures of filing Voluntary Disclosure Form and the circumstances in which such form needs to be submitted to the authority. More importantly, such amendment to original tax returns warranted penalties as per Cabinet Resolution (40) of 2017. 
As per such resolution, the submittal of an incorrect tax return by the registrant shall attract two penalties,

•    Fixed penalty of : a) (3,000) for the first time. b) (5,000) in case of repetition
•    Percentage based penalty shall be applied on the amount unpaid to the Authority due to the error and resulting in a tax benefit as follows: 

-(5%) if the Registrant makes a voluntary disclosure before being notified of the tax audit by the Authority

Further, where a Taxable Person fails to settle the Payable Tax stated in the submitted Tax Return or Tax Assessment he was notified of, within the timeframe specified in the Tax Law shall be obligated to pay a late payment penalty consisting of: 

•    (2%) of the unpaid tax is due immediately once the payment of Payable Tax is late; 
•    (4%) is due on the seventh day following the deadline for payment, on the amount of tax which is still unpaid. 
•    (1%) daily penalty charged on any amount that is still unpaid one calendar month following the deadline for payment with upper ceiling of (300%).

Though these provisions of the Resolution may seem straight forward, there are some confusions which has been crept in. Let us have a closer look at these grey areas of the resolution. 

The decree clearly states that there are fixed and flexible penalties involved in filing a Voluntary Disclosure Form but also states that there will be penalties on unpaid taxes from such original date on which he was obligated to pay tax to the Federal Tax Authority. 
There is a visible confusion here which we believe the reader has already contemplated. Let us take you through an example to ward off any confusions whatsoever. 

Example:

Consider a scenario where ABC LLC, a tax registrant in Dubai, during an internal audit review identified that they missed out to account few sales in the system and disclose the same in his tax return. ABC LLC, as per their advice received from their tax advisors, are filing a Voluntary Disclosure Form for that particular tax period to rectify this error.

ABC LLC understands that they will have a fixed penalty of AED 3,000 while accessing the VDF and an additional 5% penalty on the unpaid tax as he is disclosing this voluntarily without any notification from the FTA.

But, upon filing, ABC LLC noticed that the penalty is much larger than they had anticipated. While reviewing further, it was identified that the FTA system has charged non-payment penalty to their account. To their surprise, such non-payment penalty has been computed from the original due date of the return for which ABC LLC filed VDF. 

ABC LLC and in real life, various tax registrants in the country felt that such non-payment penalty shall not be levied in cases where a Voluntary Disclosure Form has been submitted. It was their opinion that such penalty takes away the intention of filing a Voluntary Disclosure Form. 

This how the subject matter became a dispute and moved to the Federal Supreme Court of UAE.

Observations of the Court

The honourable court observed that

a) the relation between the Federal Tax Authority and the taxable person is not a contractual relationship but an organized one, ruled by peremptory legal rules.

b) Return and voluntary self-certification are due to the payable tax to be paid. There should be an outage cost for the delay of paying the due tax stated in the voluntary self-certification to be paid according to Article 9 of the table no. 1 attached with the Cabinet decision no. 40 for 2017, and it is not dispraising to say that applying outage cost is in case not paying the due tax without the voluntary self-certification.

c) Saying not applying outage cost on the stated tax in the voluntary self-certification is considered a pretext to depriving the treasury of the due taxes for a long time till submitting the voluntary self-certification and its paying is subject to the willing of the taxable person.

  d) Inaction of paying the due tax in due time requires applying the outage cost whether it is stated in the return or the voluntary self-certification.
Let us take you through the crux of the Federal Court Verdict. The honourable Court ruled that irrespective of whether a Voluntary Disclosure Form is filed, non-payment penalty will be levied on the non-payment from the due date of the tax return and not from the date of filing the Voluntary Disclosure Form.  

Conclusion

This decisive ruling from the Federal Court culminates a long-standing disparity in the interpretation of the law.  Even as we agree that this decision might have a huge financial impact on the businesses, it is rather imperative to have a foolproof tax system to avoid such compliance costs. A pretax audit review of your organization can go a long way in identifying the gaps between UAE tax law and your tax systems and can help you take proactive decisions in the changing compliance landscapes of the country.     

Looking for TAX Services in the UAE?

We provide:

For Tax Services in Dubai:
Mr Pradeep Sai
sai@emiratesca.com
+971 – 556530001

For Tax Services in Abu Dhabi:
Mr Navaneeth
nav@emiratesca.com
+971 – 558892750

For Tax Services in Northern Emirate (Sharjah, Ajman, RAK, Fujairah)
Mr Praveen
praveen@emiratesca.com
+971 – 508873115


 

© 2020 Emirates Chartered Accountants Group